To spot the Church of Santa Maria dell’Itria, look ahead for an ornate, weathered façade packed with tall Corinthian columns and an arched doorway, topped by sculpted details and a greenish metal door that all seem to whisper stories from centuries past.
Now, pause right where you are and allow your senses to travel back in time - we’re about to step into one of Trapani’s most captivating tales. The Church of Santa Maria dell’Itria, sometimes cheekily called Santa Rita by locals because of the devotion to Saint Rita of Cascia and the relics of venerable Fra Santo di San Domenico, stands like an elaborate gatekeeper between past and present. Imagine the feeling of footsteps echoing off stone as you walk along Via Garibaldi and see the dramatic baroque façade rising before you.
Its history? Oh, it’s as layered as a good lasagna. The story starts in 1621, during Spanish rule, when the barefoot Augustinian monks decided they needed a home. They teamed up with the Confraternity of Santa Maria dell’Itria, who already had a church here, and set out to build not just a church, but a whole convent. But just three years later, in 1624, catastrophe struck Trapani - a deadly plague swept through the city like a shadow across cobblestones. Inside these very walls, the monastery’s peaceful life was shattered as all but one of the eighteen friars fell to the illness. Imagine the silence and the creak of the door at night, knowing you might be the last brother left. You could joke, “The Grim Reaper must’ve liked the Augustinians best - he took almost all of them!”
Years later, the church rose again with even more splendor. On January 29th, 1687, Bishop Bartolomeo Castelli held a grand consecration - picture crowds in candlelit processions, their prayers spiraling skyward as the church stood strong once more. But don’t get too attached to the statues you see in old pictures - the façade, designed by Pietro Castro in 1745, originally had four statues in its niches, representing the first canonized Augustinian saints. During a 19th-century sprucing-up in 1827, those statues were knocked down faster than you can say “restoration mistake.”
Step inside in your imagination, and you’re greeted by richly decorated chapels on both sides of the nave. To the right, you’ll find paintings by the legendary Giuseppe Felice, and the martyred remains of saints quietly resting beneath altars. You might even sense a chill at the idea of such relics so close by - or maybe that’s just the drafty Sicilian air. One chapel tells the story of Mary Odigitria, another shows the purity of the Immaculate Conception, and yet another is dedicated to Saint Augustine himself, with heartfelt paintings above and martyred holy men below. To the left, you’ll see depictions of the Archangel Raphael guiding young Tobias, a powerful crucifix framed by giant reliquaries, and the Ecstasy of Saint Nicholas of Tolentino.
Let’s not forget the high altar: marble crafted by Neapolitan artisans, statues of the holy family by local master Andrea Tipa - and, in a room nearby, the scent of old cypress and walnut from a grand sacristy wardrobe. Here’s where you’d find a huge painting by Domenico La Bruna, showing God gently handing the Baby Jesus to Mary and Joseph.
After 1861, the attached convent changed hands, thanks to state confiscation. If you hear voices reciting math equations or scientific formulas, it’s probably just the students of the Vincenzo Fardella High School, which moved in in 1923. There’s even an oratory here, home to paintings of Mary’s life and mysteries so captivating you might just imagine the artists hunched over canvases, candles burning low, shaping the church’s secrets for the next generation.
And after all that, the Confraternity of Santa Maria dell’Itria still calls this place home. So whether you’re a saint-seeker, an art lover, or just someone who enjoys a good ghost story, this church has it all. Just beware: history loves to linger in the marble and among the shadows.
Curious about the external, internal or the works? Don't hesitate to reach out in the chat section for additional details.
